The Rolling Pin

About

Bakeries, Custom Cakes, Cupcakes

Price Range : Moderate ($$)

  • star
    Yelp rating
    3.5 stars

Location

Adress: 1387 Rt 25A, East Setauket, NY 11733

Phone: (631) 689-2253

Work Hours

Mon6:00 am-7:00 pm
Tue6:00 am-7:00 pm
Wed6:00 am-7:00 pm
Thu6:00 am-7:00 pm
Fri6:00 am-7:00 pm
Sat6:00 am-7:00 pm
Sun6:00 am-5:00 pm

Business info

  • directions_car
    Delivery
    Yes
  • move_to_inbox
    Take-out
    Yes
  • credit_card
    Accepts Credit Cards
    Yes
  • tap_and_play
    Accepts Apple Pay
    No
  • local_parking
    Parking
    Private Lot
  • local_parking
    Bike Parking
    Yes
  • fastfood
    Caters
    Yes

Reviews

  • Tatiana Kotov

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 1 September 2026

    Spent 30 minutes ordering a cake last weekend. Was a long time wasted, the sales person couldn’t answer any questions or recommend much, but we got there. Arriving to pick it up for the party, no cake or order in site. Now have to find a cake for 40 people last minute. Never again!

  • Lynn Guan

    star star star star star 23 August 2026

    Belated thank you to the Rolling Pin Bakery for creating the most amazing Birthday cake for my daughter's 10th birthday in Dec 2018 and to celebrate her first Nutcracker performance with Seiskaya Ballet at the Staller Center in Stony Brook University. "The cake tastes as great as it looks"...this is the best compliment I would like to share with you...thank you very much!

  • Gigi Santomauro

    star star star star star 22 August 2026

    The cake we ordered for my grand daughter came out beautiful!!!!

  • Christopher De Francis

    star star star star star 22 August 2026

    My wife and I got married back in May. We were so excited to get married and we wanted to have a wedding cake that reflected that excitement. We worked with Lorraine and David on the cake tasting and the wedding cake design. It came out great! We picked ribbon for the cake and at first I was very much on the fence- who puts ribbon on a cake? Well... it was beautiful! The ribbon matched the bridesmaid’s dresses and the cream color of the cake complimented the lighting of the reception hall! Not only did the cake look great but it tasted great! We picked marble cake with cannoli cream- it was a big hit! Normally I skip the wedding cake at a wedding... looks nice but that's about it... not in this case! The Rolling Pin makes delicious cakes that are truly a work of art. David and Lorraine will work with you to make the best wedding cake for an excellent price! Thank you Rolling Pin for doing a great job and making our special day even more special!

  • Michael S

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 21 August 2026

    We were told they could make a gluten free, egg free cake for my son's first birthday. They sent an email the morning of the party and told us they couldn't do it. So very upset with them. They lied to us and ruined our son's first birthday cake.

People Recommend